The land kept its riches in the dark, sprouting no trees with fruit.
Mexican Gothic by Silvia Moreno-Garcia
For fans of: Dracula, Kindred, The Yellow Wallpaper, Get Out
The hype around Mexican Gothic on book Twitter built swiftly and steadily, like a hurricane. Swept away, I hurried to Bookshop.org to order my copy before it sold out. When it arrived, though, I shelved it in favor of Patsy by Nicole Dennis-Benn. Why?
Between the cover and the synopsis, and the author’s skillful Twitter promotion, I knew I’d be hooked by this book. I get a strange feeling when I have a to-read list that’s too exciting: I don’t want to be through with the anticipation, done with the feeling of being sucked in to a story. That feeling was especially strong with Mexican Gothic.
Well?
Reader, I finished it in a day.
Some reviewers complained it started too slowly; I was very surprised to read that. Silvia Moreno-Garcia’s writing never wavers from pushing the plot forwards. Her sentences tend towards brusque, but not blunt. They create drumbeats. Hear this:
He took off the robe, placing it around her shoulders. It was too large. He was tall and she was not. It never bothered her much, tall men. She simply looked them up and down.
Part of this style comes from the strong voice of the protagonist, Noemí, who is charmingly self-assured and headstrong. Noemí makes for an entertaining inversion of the typical Gothic woman, who is too often fragile, nervous, and melodramatic. Moreno-Garcia demonstrates great skill in trapping this capable protagonist without an abundance of what I might call the eyeroll effect: that feeling when the movie theater collectively wonders why so many white families buy obviously haunted houses.
The horror-logic of Mexican Gothic is intricately constructed, ratcheting up drama in tandem with its constraints on the protagonists. There’s often little time to wonder why Noemí doesn’t just leave, or fight, before it’s made painfully clear her entrapment.
One reason it works so well is the hostage: as in Dracula, the protagonist is fighting against evil not because she’s too stubborn or stupid to leave, but because a loved one is in the fight of her life. I love this device in horror because it’s so eminently believable. Neither, too, does Moreno-Garcia take advantage of the trope. Catalina is lovable, and Moreno-Garcia crafts some truly creepy scenes early on to hint at the danger she’s in at High Place.
Ah, and we get to High Place. The other column of Mexican Gothic’s horror-logic, a fresh rendition of the Gothic house borne of works like The Fall of the House of Usher and The Yellow Wallpaper – to which you will find many allusions. High Place as a horror setting slow-burns. Like all Gothic settings it’s immediately unwelcoming, then quickly foreboding; but Mexican Gothic takes its time in revealing the true secrets and spookiness of the old English Manor and its inhabitants.
I don’t want to get into detail about High Place or the Doyles, the ex-pat English exiles who inhabit it, because the care with which Moreno-Garcia reveals every thread of their lore shouldn’t be preempted. Just know you’re in for a tale of Gothic colonization, the multifaceted horrors of racism, and a legend of the deep mire.
Just go read it!
Worms, stems, the snake in the grass rose and wrapped itself around Noemí’s neck.
You’re ours, like it or not. You’re ours and you’re us.
Mexican Gothic, Silvia Moreno-Garcia
